Sourdough Troubleshooting: Common Problems and How to Fix Them

Have you ever prepared your sourdough dough with care, only to find that the results fell flat—literally? Whether it’s flat loaves, a tough crust, or a sourdough starter that just won’t cooperate, troubleshooting can make all the difference in your baking success. But don’t worry, mastering sourdough is within reach! With the right techniques and tools, like a banneton basket, you can elevate your baking game and fix those common sourdough problems. Ready to troubleshoot your way to the perfect loaf? Let’s explore some solutions.

Flat or Deflated Loaves

The Problem: After proofing and baking, your loaf looks more like a pancake than a beautifully risen bread.

The Fix: Flat loaves are often caused by improper proofing—either over-proofing or under-proofing your dough. A great way to avoid this is by using a bread-proofing basket or a banneton bread basket, which helps support the dough and ensure even proofing. This helps the dough maintain its shape and rise fully in the oven. To check if your dough is ready to bake, gently press a finger into it. If the indentation springs back slowly, you’re good to go.

Pro Tip: Pay attention to room temperature—too hot or too cold can also affect proofing times.

Dense or Gummy Bread

The Problem: After slicing into your sourdough loaf, you’re met with a dense, gummy texture instead of the light, airy crumb you hoped for.

The Fix: Poor gluten development or cutting the bread too early can result in a dense or gummy loaf. To improve gluten development, try folding your dough several times during the bulk fermentation. Also, resist the temptation to slice into the loaf too soon after baking! Let your bread cool completely before slicing to avoid a gummy interior. For better structure, using a banneton basket kit ensures your dough is evenly supported as it proofs.

Pro Tip: Use a dough whisk to mix your ingredients well and incorporate plenty of air.

Sourdough Starter Not Rising

The Problem: Your sourdough starter is sluggish and doesn’t rise after feeding, making it hard to get your dough to rise.

The Fix: A weak or inactive starter can usually be revived with regular feedings of equal parts water and flour. Storing your starter in a cool place can also keep it from fermenting too quickly. If your starter still isn’t rising, try feeding it more frequently or adjusting the flour-to-water ratio. Using a bread-proofing basket kit helps to maintain the right conditions for your starter to thrive.

Pro Tip: Feed your starter consistently at the same time each day to keep it active.

Crust Is Too Hard or Soft

The Problem: Your sourdough crust is either too tough and thick, or too soft and under-baked.

The Fix: Achieving the perfect crust requires proper steam and temperature control. Make sure your oven is preheated to around 450°F and that you have enough moisture in the oven for a crispy crust. If the crust is too hard, you may be baking it at too high a temperature or for too long. On the flip side, for soft crusts, ensure that the loaf has cooled completely before cutting. Using a banneton bread basket during proofing can help control moisture and achieve an even crust.

Superbaking Bread Proofing Basket Kit

For all your sourdough troubleshooting needs, the Superbaking Bread Proofing Basket Kit is your perfect partner. This all-in-one kit includes a banneton basket for even dough shaping, a cloth liner, a scoring knife for professional designs, and a dough whisk for easy mixing. It also features extra blades, a faux leather cover, a plastic brush, and both metal and plastic scrapers to make your sourdough journey smoother.

What makes the Superbaking kit stand out is its beginner-friendly design and environmentally-friendly materials. The splinter-free finish ensures comfort, while its food-safe construction makes it ideal for home bakers. Plus, you can rest easy with Superbaking’s 100% Customer Happiness Guarantee. Whether you're just starting out or looking to perfect your craft, this kit has everything you need for a successful sourdough experience.

P.S. To be notified on our newest blog posts about recipes, news, and tips on bread baking, and to get access to Superbaking’s exciting special offers and promos on our premium baking tools, become a VIP member by subscribing to our mailing list here or joining our Facebook group community here.